What Is Going on in Minnesota? and Wisconsin?

By July 6, 2020 Commentary

The heretofore common coronavirus strains were fairly seasonal, at least in the temperate latitudes where most studies have been done.  Infections dropped off dramatically beginning in June and continuing until October.  No one really understands why-the virus doesn’t like warm and humid weather, vitamin D levels, we are indoors/outdoors more, ultraviolet levels, etc. have been advanced as explanations.  And this strain definitely is operating on a weird pattern.  The northeast’s drop in cases I understand, they had such bad infection levels near the start that if you buy the T cell argument, they probably have enough population immunity to slow spread and they finally stopped the stupid nursing home policies.  But why are some southern and southwestern states seeing more cases now; they are plenty hot and humid, their residents get more sunshine and should have more vitamin D year round, they get plenty of UV.  Some have suggested that influenza has a different seasonal pattern in southern states–it has a relatively higher prevalence in the summer, so maybe this coronavirus is like that.  And people in Minnesota spend plenty of time in the air-conditioned indoors.  Protests might have something to do with it, but then we should see spikes in a lot of states.  Reopenings can’t have much to do with it, many of the states were open for weeks before cases started rising and Wisconsin hasn’t had a statewide order in place since May 13, and has seen no significant rise.  Texas, California and Arizona may be seeing some border contribution and Florida claims out-of-staters represent many of the cases.  It seems like yet another mystery of the coronavirus universe.

One thing is clear, deaths and hospitalizations have fallen pretty dramatically in Minnesota.  Hospitalizations have declined from a peak of around 800 patients in a day to about 250 now.  Since June 21, a total of 15 reporting days, there have been ten or more deaths on only two days.  In the prior 15 days, there were less than ten deaths only twice.  Since long-term care residents continue to represent around 80% of deaths, not sure that we have cleaned up our act in that sector.  Leaving aside the last few days where data lags play a role, the number of cases shows no discernible trend.  Our positive rate has gone down.  It sure looks like an epidemic that has petered out.  I don’t think our rate of social distancing, mobility or mask use is any different than many other states.  Most likely explanations are some form of seasonality or enough population immunity to dramatically slow spread, through a combination of low susceptibility due to pre-existing immune defenses, and higher prevalence of infections by this strain than we currently realize.

Wisconsin is more of the same, with a continuing much lower death rate than Minnesota.  That state has only seen 58 deaths in the last 15 reporting days and the rate of growth in newly hospitalized patients has slowed to a crawl, while testing has stayed at a fairly high level.  I am sure at some point an answer will become apparent, but it isn’t right now.

 

Join the discussion 3 Comments

  • Doug Young says:

    Pretty sure the main driver of our higher case rate here in California is the increase in testing, which is partially due to our (slowish) re-opening. Many more companies (in quite a few different fields – construction, healthcare, front line workers) are requiring their employees to get tested as they come back on the job now that things are ramping up. Fear of liability seems to be driving this push.Tests are up big time the last month here and test results lag, as well, so cases may seem a bit delayed.

    I have one colleague who tested positive on the RT-PCR test ~ 7 weeks ago that he took for work and they sent him home for 2 weeks (he was asymptomatic). At 2 weeks, he tested negative on the RT-PCR and positive on the antibody test, which makes sense. But the company wants 2 consecutive negative tests before allowing him back to work, so he waited another couple of weeks. The night before the 3rd round of testing, he had an accident and cracked 2 of his ribs and went to the ER, where they put him on the Covid ward, with one other patient and 12 empty beds, 8 nurses and 3 doctors. He was treated like royalty for 2 days with all those available professionals, and then released. He couldn’t go back to work because of the ribs, so he delayed his 3rd round of testing for another couple of weeks. And then tested positive on the RT-PCR test! His doctor thinks he’s fine and that the positive results my be an artifact of a medication he takes, so has written a note allowing him to work. 2 weeks later, and he’s finally working, so they either listened to his doctor or he had a negative test (haven’t talked to him about that last part yet).

    I’m guessing that his county (San Mateo) has him down as 3 cases (1 for each positive test), and one Covid hospitalization (for his broken ribs on the Covid ward).

  • Doug Young says:

    Also a quick infograffic from Twitter on Florida cases:

    https://twitter.com/donald_scherer/status/1280225486229196800/photo/1

  • […] What is happening here? Kevin Roche comments: […]

Leave a Reply