The Texas Medical Center conducted a survey of 9000 consumers and 450 physicians in 15 large population states, asking them questions about health care spending. (TMC Survey) 91% of consumers said that having health insurance was very important to them. About 65% of respondents said they pay more than 5% of their income out-of-pocket for health care related products and services and 49% indicated that they cut other spending in order to pay for health care. Among uninsured respondents, 2% of income was an indication of the most they could afford to pay for health insurance or health care, and 55% of the uninsured said expense was the main reason they didn’t have insurance. (I just want to briefly interject that a lot of these uninsured individuals are finding money for unhealthy things, like cigarettes, fast or unhealthy food, alcohol, etc.) Why are costs high and rising? 47% of physicians and 28% of consumers blame insurance companies, 30% of consumers and 19% of doctors blame drug and medical device companies and 23% of consumers and 12% of physicians blame the federal government, while only 10% of consumers and 9% of doctors lay fault on hospitals and almost no one ascribes it to doctors. Hard to fix the problem when you are so wrong about the causes. Providers, and the product companies, are the very predominant cause of increased spending. And doctors are especially at fault, since they are the ones ordering almost every service. How do we solve this mess? The respondents, correctly in my view, say we should raise costs for people who engage in unhealthy habits, 40% of doctors and 28% of consumers (of course, the consumer respondents must not think any of them fit in this category); make cheaper catastrophic coverage only insurance available, 23% of physicians and consumers; and encourage doctors to follow practice guidelines, about 20% of overall respondents (just want to note that if you think this is a solution, you should have acknowledged that doctors may be responsible for higher spending). According to the physician respondents, only a third are paid on a salary basis and most have some compensation method that rewards volume. About 70% of doctors think that the ideal system is either all salary or just very small incentives. Cognitive dissonance at work again, since only 2% of the physicians thought they had any responsibility for higher spending. While the survey confirms the pain high spending is causing, lack of knowledge about its sources and potential remedies is obviously an impediment to fixing the problem.
About this Blog
The Healthy Skeptic is a website about the health care system, and is written by Kevin Roche, who has many years of experience working in the health industry. Mr. Roche is available to assist health care companies through consulting arrangements through Roche Consulting, LLC and may be reached at [email protected].
Healthy Skeptic Podcast
Subscribe to Blog via Email
As is usually the case in health care, the big just keep getting bigger. UnitedHealth Group’s Optum division is buying NaviHealth, which helps manage post-acute care for Medicare Advantage members.
May 20, 2020
Stellar Health shines as it raises $10 million in new financing for its business of aiding providers and payers in doing value-based care.
May 14, 2020
Another typical post. For new readers, this blog usually is all health care business, policy, and research and one staple is me making fun of the ridiculous names people put...
May 7, 2020
MedPAC 2019 Report to Congress
June 18, 2019