It is fairly undisputed that both health insurance and provider (especially hospital) markets have become more concentrated. The impact of this concentration on provider prices and on insurance premiums is heavily debated and probably highly interactive, with a four-way matrix of relative hospital and insurer concentration leading to different outcomes in pricing. Research published in the Journal of Health Economics attempts to untangle these effects. (Health Econ. Article) The researchers looked at employer-sponsored insurance and used a Kaiser foundation database to secure premium information over the years 2006 to 2011. They also constructed HHI measures of market concentration for the health insurance and hospital markets using standard databases on insurers and hospitals. Only fully-insured plans were used to measure premiums, but a plan’s share of both insured and self-funded business was used to determine relative bargaining power with providers. Looking at the HHI for health plans and hospitals, there was heterogeneity in markets. Some markets had insurers with more concentration, and presumably more bargaining leverage, than hospitals; some markets with hospital systems with more concentration and bargaining leverage, and some with relatively equal power. In regard to fully-insured employer coverage, almost 100% of the geographic markets are either moderately or heavily concentrated (keep that in mind in light of the latest proposed large health plan consolidations). In regard to bargaining with hospitals, there are a significant number of markets, about 27%, that are unconcentrated from a health plan perspective. As we would expect, greater health plan concentration is associated both with higher premiums for fully-insured plans and lower prices paid to hospitals. (It is a separate question whether consumers see the benefits of those lower prices. The higher premiums would suggest they don’t, but MLR requirements may ameliorate some of that effect.) Markets which have greater levels of hospital concentration have higher premiums as well. The bottom line is that the best situation for buyers of health coverage appears to be to have both a competitive plan and a competitive hospital market; that likely results in the lowest premiums. Unfortunately, what we have in many, if not most, markets is an oligopoly of both plans and hospitals and in those markets the parties likely quickly realize that the best outcome is for the hospitals to get paid more and the plans just pass that on to their customers in the form of marked-up, higher premiums.
✅ Subscribe via Email
About this Blog
The Healthy Skeptic is a website about the health care system, and is written by Kevin Roche, who has many years of experience working in the health industry. Mr. Roche is available to assist health care companies through consulting arrangements through Roche Consulting, LLC and may be reached at [email protected].
Healthy Skeptic Podcast
This is an outstanding report on total global drug spending and trends, with projections out to 2025. It helps you understand this important area of health care, which does much...
June 1, 2021
MedPAC 2019 Report to Congress
June 18, 2019
More money pouring into young health care companies as Dispatch Health gains $330 million in new capital to deliver high acuity health care in a patient’s home, rather than a...
November 30, 2022
A lot of money is invested in health care startups and growth companies, since health care is 20% of the economy, but the returns aren’t always good. Here is another...
November 1, 2022
HealthJoy delights investors by garnering $60 million in mindless new capital to support its benefits navigation tool. Another sign of too much capital still floating around out there.
November 1, 2022
Access ACO Care Management Chronic Disease Comparative Effectiveness Consumer Directed Health Consumers Devices Disease Management Drugs EHRs Elder Care End-of-Life Care FDA Financings Genomics Government Health Care Costs Health Care Quality Health Care Reform Health Insurance Health Insurance Exchange HIT HomeCare Hospital Hospital Readmissions Legislation M&A Malpractice Meaningful Use Medicaid Medical Care Medicare Medicare Advantage Mobile Pay For Performance Pharmaceutical Physicians Providers Regulation Repealing Reform Telehealth Telemedicine Wellness and Prevention Workplace