Research published in the Journal of the American Medical Association finds itself at the intersection of two controversies–geographic variation in utilization and spending and the relative value of Medicare Advantage plans versus traditional Medicare. (JAMA Article) The researchers looked at common cardiovascular procedures to ascertain the relative rates of use both in various locales and between the fee-for-service and Medicare Advantage programs. Angiography, bypass surgery and stenting were the procedures and hospital referral regions were the geographic unit. In general, Medicare Advantage beneficiaries had substantially lower rates per thousand person-years for angiography–16.5 vs. 25.9 for fee-for-service; PCI–6.8 vs.9.8; but more similar rates for bypass surgery–3.1 vs. 3.5. Interestingly urgent angiography and stenting rates were very similar; indicating that the reductions in use for MA patients was due to more cautious elective use of the procedures. However, Medicare Advantage showed equally great geographic variation in the rates of use of the procedures as did fee-for-service. The range of variation is three to four-fold for each procedure, which is simply astounding. The reasons for the variation are unclear, but other research is zeroing in on both population health differences and regional practice pattern preferences by providers. To the extent that population health characteristics are the driver, the variation is acceptable; to the extent that it merely reflects provider practice preferences, there is a clear opportunity to encourage the providers with high procedure rates to reexamine the appropriateness of their utilization.
Geographic Variation in MA Plans Compared to Medicare Fee-for-Service
No Comments
✅ Subscribe via Email
About this Blog
Healthy Skeptic Podcast
Research
MedPAC 2019 Report to Congress
June 18, 2019
Headlines
Tags
Access
ACO
Care Management
Chronic Disease
Comparative Effectiveness
Consumer Directed Health
Consumers
Devices
Disease Management
Drugs
EHRs
Elder Care
End-of-Life Care
FDA
Financings
Genomics
Government
Health Care Costs
Health Care Quality
Health Care Reform
Health Insurance
Health Insurance Exchange
HIT
HomeCare
Hospital
Hospital Readmissions
Legislation
M&A
Malpractice
Meaningful Use
Medicaid
Medical Care
Medicare
Medicare Advantage
Mobile
Pay For Performance
Pharmaceutical
Physicians
Providers
Regulation
Repealing Reform
Telehealth
Telemedicine
Wellness and Prevention
Workplace
Related Posts
Commentary
March 21, 2023
Minnesota’s New Energy Insanity, Part 7
Minnesota is a particularly poor place to rely on solar power, but other states aren't…
Commentary
March 21, 2023
A Quick SVB Follow-up
As I suspected, the SVB saga is primarily one of regulatory malfeasance, coupled with political…
Commentary
March 19, 2023
Tom Frieden Speaks in the WSJ
A public health expert writes an article for the WSJ which amply demonstrates why Americans…