Alleged overuse of medical services has been said to cause tens of billions of dollars of unnecessary spending every year. A variety of methods have been suggested to avoid this overuse and the managed care industry came about in part as a way to help ensure appropriate service use. A review of the research finds that no particular system of care seems to be better than another at tackling this problem. (Med. Care Article) The authors found only seven research reports that they deemed useful for a comparison of systems to address overuse. The articles looked at 3 procedures, one diagnostic test and one medication. For example, carotid endarterectomy was used inappropriately to the same extent in Medicare FFS and Medicare Advantage. Overuse of antibiotics for the treatment of upper respiratory infection were higher in a staff model managed care plan than a FFS plan. Another study did find lower use of certain diagnostic services in a managed care setting versus FFS. The VA system had rates of inappropriate use similar or even higher than those in private settings. The reality is that this review is too limit to draw any meaningful conclusions, but it would appear that physicians will order services inappropriately whether they are paid a salary or get a fee-for-service payment and whether they are treating HMO patients or Medicare beneficiaries or any other patients. There is other evidence finding that certain organized systems may ensure better adherence to best care practice guidelines. The underlying problem may be that if we want patients’ wishes to be followed, patients often want unnecessary tests and treatments. And the notion that overuse costs us lots of money is surely overstated and ignores the other side of the coin; that there are many patients who don’t get services that they should get.
✅ Subscribe via Email
About this Blog
The Healthy Skeptic is a website about the health care system, and is written by Kevin Roche, who has many years of experience working in the health industry. Mr. Roche is available to assist health care companies through consulting arrangements through Roche Consulting, LLC and may be reached at [email protected].
Healthy Skeptic Podcast
This is an outstanding report on total global drug spending and trends, with projections out to 2025. It helps you understand this important area of health care, which does much...
June 1, 2021
MedPAC 2019 Report to Congress
June 18, 2019
Mental health company Headway makes, well, headway, by raising an impressive $125 million round of new capital. The company connects patients with mental health providers and facilitates providers working with...
October 11, 2023
Two health care firms owned by private equity firms are merging in a transaction supposedly valued at $3 billion. HealthComp administers self-funded plans for employers and other groups and Virgin...
September 27, 2023
NextGen, an electronic medical records firm, is being put out of its public company misery, as a PE firm will pay $1.6 billion for the one-time high-flier.
September 7, 2023
Access ACO Care Management Chronic Disease Comparative Effectiveness Consumer Directed Health Consumers Devices Disease Management Drugs EHRs Elder Care End-of-Life Care FDA Financings Genomics Government Health Care Costs Health Care Quality Health Care Reform Health Insurance Health Insurance Exchange HIT HomeCare Hospital Hospital Readmissions Legislation M&A Malpractice Meaningful Use Medicaid Medical Care Medicare Medicare Advantage Mobile Pay For Performance Pharmaceutical Physicians Providers Regulation Repealing Reform Telehealth Telemedicine Wellness and Prevention Workplace