Not All Immigrants Are Beneficial

By October 25, 2026Commentary4 min read

Immigration into the United States is a good thing.  It should bring people who are attracted to our relatively free-market economy and free society.  These people are generally hard working and want to take the opportunity to improve their economic and other status.  Immigrants can bring skills which are needed in our economy and in short supply.  We need more immigrants with these characteristics.  That all assumes that immigrants come in legally and are screened.  Illegal immigration should never be tolerated.  “Refugee” status should not be a basis by itself for legal immigration.  People need to stay and play a role in fixing their native countries, not come to ours just to escape.  And the refugee populations are often troublesome, particularly from undeveloped countries.

Minnesota is an excellent example of positive and more negative immigration.  We have a significant Hmong population, which came in the aftermath of the Vietnam war, but the numbers who were settled here was limited.  Many were refugees.  But they brought a respect for rules and order and a willingness to adapt to the values and social mores common in the US.  They have thrived in Minnesota and elsewhere.  And then there are the Somalis, who come from a corrupt country, largely Muslim, that was subject to extensive clan and tribal conflicts.  While there are many Somalis who work hard, value family and attempt to obey the law; there is also an extensive group of Somalis, both in Minnesota and elsewhere, who brought their culture of corruption with them and have continued their legacy of clan and tribal conflict.

Thus we see the widespread fraud on government programs, likely enabled in part by Somalis in positions of influence.  The broader Somali community pretty much completely failed to come forward to expose the fraud, in part out of fear but also because they just accept that kind of corruption.  We can only imagine the amount of tax fraud that occurs.  And we have a substantial crime wave, not just in the Twin Cities but even in the outstate, due to Somali gangs.  So I don’t have any interest in hearing how important the Somalis have been to Minnesota.  On the whole, just from an economic perspective, they cost the state and its taxpayers far more than they contribute.  The Somali “community” has had little interest in fixing that or in stopping the gang-driven crime.

You can see more information on just how expensive importing so many Somalis to Minnesota has been in the set of charts and other data points here.   (CIS Post)  The Somalis have not really integrated into Minnesota, they have largely stayed separate.  While they tend to be an intelligent people, they also are arrogant in many ways, believing their Muslim religion makes them superior.  The Democrats who run Minnesota have not just failed to address these issues, they have facilitated the behavior, largely because they rely on Somali votes and voter fraud to stay in power.  We should not allow any group coming from a country like Somalia into the country, the risks of non-integration and bad behavior are too high.  And if they do come, extensive efforts should be made to educate them on US laws and values and expectations.  It is too late for Minnesota, we have paid a very high price for allowing so many Somalis in and we will continue to pay that price into the forseeable future.

Kevin Roche

Author Kevin Roche

The Healthy Skeptic is a website about the health care system, and is written by Kevin Roche, who has many years of experience working in the health industry through Roche Consulting, LLC. Mr. Roche is available to assist health care companies through consulting arrangements and may be reached at khroche@healthy-skeptic.com.

More posts by Kevin Roche

Join the discussion 2 Comments

  • The immigration act of 1965, the Hart-Cellar Act, changed everything. Between 1790 and 1965, 40 million immigrants arrived in the states. Between 1920 to 1965, specifically, America allowed in only 6 million legal immigrants. So, after about 1900, immigration to the US was a trickle. Then the 1965 act was passed, with help and dishonesty from the morally and intellectually challenged Lion of the Senate.

    Between 1965 and 2025, 72 MILLION legal immigrants arrived.

    So, if we maintain that this enormous number is a problem, then America has a legal immigration problem. People disagree. Open border haters of the nation state want more legal immigration.

    What’s going on with ICE is theater.

  • BJ says:

    Your state used to be the Land of Ten Thousand Lakes, Kevin. Now it’s the state of Ten Thousand Learing Centers. You’ve imported the third world and now, sad to say, your state is becoming the third world. Yes, many wonderful people but the Somalis have no interest in assimilating-just exploiting your state’s “suicidal empathy”.
    There will be a time when you will have to start sending them back under the rule of reciprocity. No Christians there, no Muslims here.

Leave a Reply