I hope people find some of these reviews interesting. I do them solely to give people ideas about people or things to learn about. This book, All Quiet on the Western Front by Erich Remarque, was written by a German following the first world war. It is short and very readable, a first person account by a German soldier of his experience of intense trench warfare. It was a forerunner of the now-common war novel giving a realistic depiction of the horrors, which become commonplace for the soldiers, and destruction of war; and of the mental processes and reactions of these soldiers to being placed in this situation. And for the truth that the young people who make all the sacrifices are just pawns for old men to use in pursuit of vanity. Talking about you here Vladimir Putin, the barbarian par excellence. And it was actually the Ukraine war that sparked me to re-read this book, which I last read in college. We see in Ukraine exactly what happened in WWI. I strongly, strongly encourage all of you to pick up this book and be reminded how wasteful and traumatic war is.
We here in the US have repeatedly seen the impact in recent decades of what happens to the men, and now women, that we send into these conflicts–Vietnam, Iraq, etc. All Quiet shows that nothing has changed for over 100 years–participation in actual sustained combat fundamentally changes and damages people. And despite the immense damage to people and to economies as well, we see no change in the willingness of some leaders, none of whom you will find on the battlefield, to send hundred, thousands, hundreds of thousands, millions of soldiers to be killed or maimed. We see no real commitment by these delusional thugs to peaceful solution of disputes; although it is by now clear that it isn’t really disputes, but vanity that drives these violent conflicts–Putin, Xi, the Ayotallah, the nutbag in North Korea, just take a look at what they are.
So we can write all the books, sing all the songs, film all the movies with the same message–Masters of War, The Thin Red Line, Apocalypse Now, Fortunate Sun, and on and on, but that message isn’t being heard by those vain leaders. So the destruction of lives and waste of money and physical assets will continue, to humanity’s great detriment.
These reviews are interesting and good variety against hearing more about Nebraska Fats.
“So the destruction of lives and waste of money and physical assets will continue, to humanity’s great detriment.” That has been, is now, and will be because according to 1John5:19: “We know that we are of God, and that the whole world lies in the power of the evil one.” Psalm 78 provides the solution: “Because they did not believe in God and did not trust in His salvation”.
well stated. a recommendation, The Long Gray Line – the West Point Class of 1966. they had to most causalities of any class prior or since then. a moving account of not just the solider but also their families.
Thank you Dan, an excellent recommendation
I think “Come and See” is the most powerful war movie I’ve ever seen. Hard to watch. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zjIiApN6cfg
thank you for the recommendation, good for people to have lots of material on this topic
The WW I documentary film “They Shall Not Grow Old,” is a tremendously moving (and extraordinarily well-done) collection of actual filming done by British military photographers during that war. Beautifully colorized for our “modern” eyes.
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7905466/
…and it was merely “Act One” of the 20th Century.
A blogger whose “nom de ‘net” is “Grim Beorn” has a series of posts on the Anabasis of Xenophon, from 401 BC. … posts in which he comments on and summarizes the parts as he reads them. …you have internecine conflict, territorial landgrabs, cowardice and heroism. It almost could have been written today….
Home page is here: https://grimbeorn.blogspot.com/
His Anabasis series starts here: https://grimbeorn.blogspot.com/2025/01/anabasis-i.html
yes, it is depressing how humans collectively don’t seem to learn and keep repeating the same behaviors with ever-more deadly weapons.
For some reason I associate modernity with civilized, commom-sense problem solving. But human nature seems to have negative, fixed traits that never go away. When I was a lad, there was a commercial promoting that the leaders of nations – the ones who resist peaceful resolution or demand their own way, go to the top of a hill and duke it out; save the lives of innocent peoples who have nothing against each other.