The health care system often relies on patients to provide information, sometimes about symptoms or activities or adherence to treatment plans and sometimes more formally as patient-reported outcomes in research. Those of you who watched the medical show House know that he always believed patients lied. While it may not be as extreme as that, there is good reason to be concerned about the accuracy of information provided by patients. Knowing the frequency of inaccurate information and whether inaccuracy is more prevalent for certain kinds of data could help clinicians and researchers adjust accordingly. A poster presented at an American Health Association conference discusses this issue in the context of African Americans and heart disease. (AJMC Poster) The study looked at responses by 389 patients to a questionnaire designed to identify risk factors for cardiovascular problems. The average age was 53 and 61% were female. Patients were asked to self-report any history of certain conditions and their height and weight. They were also asked about the presence of various risk factors. 47% inaccurately reported at least one risk factor. 21% under-reported hypertension, while 1% over-reported; 25% under-reported hyperlipidemia, while 9% over-reported; 15% under-reported diabetes versus a 1% over-report; and 3% under-reported obesity and less than 1% over-reported that condition. You can see the tendency to avoid disclosure of factors that might be perceived negatively; part of the usual human tendency to be in denial. The consequences are also obvious. If clinicians relied solely on this self-reported information, they would miss many patients with higher risk factors who might need greater attention to management of their conditions to avoid acute exacerbations of heart disease. So the message to clinicians is that they shouldn’t rely on patient reported information, although it is probably worth collecting, if only to provide teachable moments for patients in regard to the importance of understanding and accurately communicating their health status and history. And for all of us as patients, we should be aware that not being fully disclosing, even of things we may be embarrassed by or not want to acknowledge, can hinder the ability of our providers to keep us in optimal health.
✅ Subscribe via Email
About this Blog
Healthy Skeptic Podcast
Research
MedPAC 2019 Report to Congress
June 18, 2019
Headlines
Tags
Access
ACO
Care Management
Chronic Disease
Comparative Effectiveness
Consumer Directed Health
Consumers
Devices
Disease Management
Drugs
EHRs
Elder Care
End-of-Life Care
FDA
Financings
Genomics
Government
Health Care Costs
Health Care Quality
Health Care Reform
Health Insurance
Health Insurance Exchange
HIT
HomeCare
Hospital
Hospital Readmissions
Legislation
M&A
Malpractice
Meaningful Use
Medicaid
Medical Care
Medicare
Medicare Advantage
Mobile
Pay For Performance
Pharmaceutical
Physicians
Providers
Regulation
Repealing Reform
Telehealth
Telemedicine
Wellness and Prevention
Workplace
Related Posts
Commentary
Variation in Health Spending
February 16, 2025
Variation in Health Spending
Another interesting analysis of geographic variation in health spending.
Commentary
All Quiet on the Western Front
February 15, 2025
All Quiet on the Western Front
The pre-eminent description of war's impact on those who must fight it was written after…
Commentary
Yesterday’s 30-year US Bond Auction Did Not Go Well
February 14, 2025
Yesterday’s 30-year US Bond Auction Did Not Go Well
Warning signs aplenty if Congress does not get its act together on deficit reduction.
Kevin, while the poster conclusion is valid…. the journalist’s conclusion about the poster was not. Patient’s inaccuracy in self-reported risk factors should is not the same as their accuracy in reporting self-reported OUTCOMES which are things like pain, functionality, appetite, mobility etc. Only patients are able to report their symptoms and the experience they have as a result of an medical intervention. Collecting PROMs is an important & valuable element of assessing the quality and impact of care.