It is a widespread belief that poor people get worse health care, and some studies have suggested that being uninsured or on Medicaid results in poorer quality hospital care. Other studies, however, have suggested that this is due more to the characteristics of the hospitals which treat more poorer patients than to insurance status or income. New research published in Health Affairs focuses on quality differences within the same hospital for varying classes of patients. (Health Affairs Article) Quality could vary within the same facility if lower payments led to less resource use for the patients covered by those lower payments or to less use of newer, more expensive treatments. It could also be the attending physicians for some classes of patients are less skilled and competent. And payer-specific quality improvement programs may differ among payers and may not affect the care of uninsured patients. The researchers looked at hospitalizations from 2006-2008 in eleven states. They looked at mortality rates for eight surgical procedures and seven medical conditions across Medicare, Medicaid, private insurance, self and no-pay and other, which included TriCare, workers’ compensation, etc. While overall the results suggested that Medicaid and self or no-pay patients had higher mortality, there were a number of cases in which private patients or Medicare patients actually showed worse outcomes by this limited measure, including on some of the most common medical conditions. The authors appear to have really strained to make the analysis fit their bias. It should be noted that the study has serious limitations, including sample sizes and the reliance on one limited quality measure. A better study would look more specifically at a large number of process and ultimate outcome measures and would ensure that all relevant patient and physician characteristics are accounted for before drawing any conclusions about the effect of payer type.
✅ Subscribe via Email
About this Blog
The Healthy Skeptic is a website about the health care system, and is written by Kevin Roche, who has many years of experience working in the health industry. Mr. Roche is available to assist health care companies through consulting arrangements through Roche Consulting, LLC and may be reached at [email protected].
Healthy Skeptic Podcast
This is an outstanding report on total global drug spending and trends, with projections out to 2025. It helps you understand this important area of health care, which does much...
June 1, 2021
MedPAC 2019 Report to Congress
June 18, 2019
What do you get when you combine a company with a commodity business model, that out of desperation massively overpays for another company that has a commodity business model? $10...
July 27, 2022
The “stupid” model for health care venture capital investing is alive and well. Everside health, which operates primary care clinics and has grown by acquiring other failing health care businesses,...
July 26, 2022
Apparently not even a cute name can save you if you have a stupid business. I constantly bemoan the mis-application of capital and health care is Exhibit A. Olive, another...
July 26, 2022
Access ACO Care Management Chronic Disease Comparative Effectiveness Consumer Directed Health Consumers Devices Disease Management Drugs EHRs Elder Care End-of-Life Care FDA Financings Genomics Government Health Care Costs Health Care Quality Health Care Reform Health Insurance Health Insurance Exchange HIT HomeCare Hospital Hospital Readmissions Legislation M&A Malpractice Meaningful Use Medicaid Medical Care Medicare Medicare Advantage Mobile Pay For Performance Pharmaceutical Physicians Providers Regulation Repealing Reform Telehealth Telemedicine Wellness and Prevention Workplace