Evaluating wellness programs is a difficult task. There are selection issues, design issues, many confounding variables and other problems. There is little well-designed research either proving or disproving cost savings. Humana issued a report evaluating the effect of its HumanaVitality wellness program. (Humana Report) The study was conducted on 8000 Humana employees using the program since 2011. The program includes pretty typical risk assessment, coaching, educational and other elements and provides an incentive to participate and meet objectives. Employees in the program supposedly had 6% lower health costs in the first year and 10% lower by the third year, compared with people not engaged in the program. Unengaged members had 56% more ER usage and 57% higher hospital visits. People with lifestyle-related chronic conditions showed the greatest decline in costs and usage. In addition, engaged employees had 6 fewer hours of unscheduled absences. Now, this study is an example of why people are so skeptical of wellness program claims. Unless you dig in pretty good, you don’t see that Humana makes up its own definition of “engaged”. Apparently all employees were judged to be in the program, but only some were “engaged”. Obviously there is room for all sorts of confounders here in terms of comparing these populations. A strange form of propensity matching was further used in the comparison. To my somewhat untrained eye, this is a suspect study with suspect conclusions.
✅ Subscribe via Email
About this Blog
The Healthy Skeptic is a website about the health care system, and is written by Kevin Roche, who has many years of experience working in the health industry. Mr. Roche is available to assist health care companies through consulting arrangements through Roche Consulting, LLC and may be reached at [email protected].
Healthy Skeptic Podcast
Research
MedPAC 2019 Report to Congress
June 18, 2019
Headlines
Tags
Access
ACO
Care Management
Chronic Disease
Comparative Effectiveness
Consumer Directed Health
Consumers
Devices
Disease Management
Drugs
EHRs
Elder Care
End-of-Life Care
FDA
Financings
Genomics
Government
Health Care Costs
Health Care Quality
Health Care Reform
Health Insurance
Health Insurance Exchange
HIT
HomeCare
Hospital
Hospital Readmissions
Legislation
M&A
Malpractice
Meaningful Use
Medicaid
Medical Care
Medicare
Medicare Advantage
Mobile
Pay For Performance
Pharmaceutical
Physicians
Providers
Regulation
Repealing Reform
Telehealth
Telemedicine
Wellness and Prevention
Workplace
Related Posts
Commentary
March 28, 2024
More Economic News
The Congressional Budget Office is expressing increasing alarm at the federal deficit and debt situation.
Commentary
March 27, 2024
Funniest Story of the Day
Would would have thought that hail could destroy a solar farm? Certainly not the nut-case…
Commentary
March 27, 2024
What Is Going on in the US Debt Markets?
The Treasury seems determined to rely on massive amounts of short-term debt to finance our…